Signal is a nonprofit. But what does this mean in practice? Today we do something most tech co’s avoid: talk money. What does it cost for Signal to play in a lane dominated by billion $ corporations, while rejecting the surveillance business model?
We’re doing this to provide transparency into Signal, and to make clear why our choice of nonprofit status isn’t just nice to have, but a fundamental safeguard against the pressures of a profitable business model that fundamentally contradicts our stance on privacy.
By being transparent about Signal, we also hope to shed light on the industry. We show how expensive the development of high- availability consumer tech is & by implication the massive profitability of the surveillance business model underwriting most tech.
We also believe it is imperative to build alternatives to the current tech ecosystem & its reliance on surveillance. And building these alternatives requires understanding the political economy of the industry, so we don’t mistake an elegant idea for a realistic possibility.
If you rely on Signal, if you believe in what we’re doing, or if you want to support tech done differently, please donate to support our work.
@signalapp I can help with German localization and Beta testing
@signalapp
I'd like to, but I've got nothing out of the possibilities of donation.
@lotharmucki @signalapp What do you mean?
@AGTMADCAT @signalapp
I got no crypto, no credit card, etc. How can I donate anyway?
@lotharmucki @signalapp Oh okay I see. If you're not in a position to have those things maybe you don't need to be donating right now? When you're secure enough to have some kind of credit card (or cheque card that works like one), you'll be in a position to pitch in. Until then, the rest of us have got you, don't worry about it. =)
@AGTMADCAT @signalapp
Very kind of you. But I'm unsure if this got still other reasons. For example illegal but still existent micro census, that block me the way to a credit card. So more payment options would be cool...
@lotharmucki @AGTMADCAT @signalapp I think people have sent cash in the mail. Not sure if they still accept or encourage it...
@lotharmucki @signalapp Beende mal die App, SEPA Zahlung wurde gerade aktiviert.
@leibi @lotharmucki @signalapp Which Version of the App do you have? I can only choose between Debit/Credit card or PayPal
@derrockwolf @lotharmucki @signalapp 6.41 Beta, I'm not sure if it works on stable too atm. Otherwise just wait 3 days.
@derrockwolf @leibi @signalapp
Me too. It's – by the way – version: 6.40.4.
@signalapp Thanks for what you are doing. I use to donate monthly, but for quite a long time now, I still get an error about my CVC being wrong. And it's not. Either for one-shot donations or monthly ones. Fix that and I *can* literally donate again... (and reintroduce SMS within the app, which counts even more since Google is ending support of AOSP SMS app, and I'd be glad to donate even more )
@Ockham @signalapp Got the same error. I held my nose and used PayPal.
@signalapp @signalapp how about an update to assign an ID like Session so we have the option of not linking phone numbers?
@leibi @signalapp thank you for the link!
@leibi @UltimusShadow @signalapp user names are an addition, not a replacement
@signalapp I still can’t export my data from Signal on iOS without buying a licence for professional cracking app, or by jailbreaking my iPhone. So it’s safe from me but not from IT professionals. That’s a choice by Signal.
@kevinteljeur @signalapp
Walled gardens plus Apple's prices are why I never have owned and never will own any iOS devices.
My advice: run yours until it quits, jailbreak it and block Apple's updates to preserve the jailbreak, get a 3ed party browser that gets regular updates outside of Apple, and block javascript on all unknown webistes to make exploits far more difficult. Also block all ads unconditionally both to help rid the Internet of monetized trash sites and to protect your device from ads bearing malware.
When the iOS device run past Apple's support period, jailbroken, and disconnected from them is lost, destroyed, or dies of electromigration, get a non-Apple phone.
My advice: get something that can run one of the AOSP-based alternate OS's and be sure not to install Google Play or anything that depends on it.
@LukefromDC @signalapp This seems like a long game plan to export some chats and photos
Going forward, I am assuming you would be reinstalling Signal on a new device if "exporting chats" is the issue. Should be possible to simply install Signal on a new phone with the old phone number and your Signal PIN. At a minimum you get your groups back going forward.
The reason this doesn't give you back previous chat data is Signal doesn't store it, your device does. This is what's for security reasons as well as keeping Signal from being forced to spend vastly more on storage.
Note that there are probably more than enough differences between Android and iOS to make creating a program that can run on both at once and make them transfer internal data between each other difficult. That would be true even without Apple's interference. Note that moving existing data from Android to iOS is also not supported, this is probably why.
I have myself never used export of data directly from Signal. Any photos inside Signal you want back, select them for download. If they are still visible in Signal they should "download" from your local database to your pictures(or whatever Apple calls it) folder. Videos will"download" to Movies (or whatever Apple calls it_ assuming you had them set to download into Signal by default or had ever played them. I am assuming here that iOS doesn't also block downloading photos and videos into the phone from Signal. If it does, see below:
In a real pinch, chats could be "saved" by bringing them up one screen at a time and photographing them on an unlocked phone or a real camera. This works entirely without regard for any locking down-and is one reason you should never assume Signal can keep one malicious party in a group chat from saving everything. If they can't screenshot it they can still photograph it, and that might look like shit but it will be readable.
Photos it would be difficult to get enough quality this way and videos even worse, but might be better than nothing. I am assuming paid software is all the way off the table as it is for me.
If you can't jailbreak the phone well enough to allow exporting your data, I would advise an immediate end to the use of it for taking photos or using chat apps for anything you care about saving on grounds of it being "write-only memory."
@signalapp $10/mo recurring.
I just donated 100 USD. Good job so far!
@signalapp Why would anyone donate to a closed, non-federated network and OS limited client ?
@signalapp as soon as you remove the cyrpto currency and return to being a private messenger app I will donate.
@signalapp My entire network uses Signal. Thank you for your transparency. Donation done!
@signalapp still not working on huawei phones with out Google surveses.. For alternative and better to WhatsApp not a good sign to not working on phones with out Google on.. What a shame
@signalapp
Asking for donations? Android users have been waiting for a tablet version for years now and you ignore us. Give me a reason why we should donate when we are being ignored.
@signalapp I donated because I realize free things, like Signal and Mastodon aren’t free, like say Facebook and Twitter. Signal and Mastodon aren’t monetizing me and selling me. To Twitter and Facebook I’m the product.
@signalapp what is your current Balance sheet?
@signalapp Hmm, decentralization might help reducing costs.
CC @slavistapl
@wnm210 @signalapp indeed, Signal should one day go being decentralised… if Signal shuts down in current model they pursue into, we would lose all our contacts likely irrevocably.
Decentralisation plus phone numbers’ privacy? A recipe for almost ideal messaging service.
@slavistapl @signalapp well actually decentralization would be harder to set up with phone numbers so I think they would add e-mails instead. I don’t know how they would solve the problem of checking the phone number on private instances.
@signalapp Signal is abundantly useful. It is interesting, also, to see how much it costs to provide services that interface with the traditional telephone network, as opposed to, say, usernames.
@signalapp Thanks for the write up. I'd love to see the phone number registration fees decrease somehow, but I trust you are doing your research and found it's the least costly option, and also better for people (saving us from spam accounts).
I've donated, and plan to donate again once I have the capacity :)
@filipe @signalapp I wonder if they consider a $1 app fee as a form of verification instead of using SMS with the user paying the fee.
No different than accepting card for donation but instead tied to one time validation. This voids the need for SMS.
@nunyab @signalapp Hmmm I'm not in favor of it. When Elmo did it we all thought it was dumb ahahaha I think maybe a national ID/passport verification as an alternative (without removing the phone option for people who need it)? That might be much cheaper?
I give this opinion because having a phone number is not anonymous anyway. And if we want to prevent spam by tying each account to a real person (basically Sybil resistance), I'd love to see national IDs/passports used more.
I know there's concerns about 1984 state surveillance stuff, but, if implemented correctly, I think we can prevent that technically(?)
@signalapp Also remember that as with all US non-profits, Signal's tax filings are public. So you can see another (if less up to date) breakdown of their expenditures at https://projects.propublica.org/nonprofits/organizations/824506840/202212729349301631/full :)
@trystimuli @signalapp yikes, what a deficit!
@signalapp great write-up. Love the transparency. Donated and would love more friends to move from WhatsApp but they don't because of network effects
@signalapp This toot needs a #privacy hashtag.
@signalapp Donated!
@signalapp this is truly an incredible post. Thank you for sharing!
@signalapp @Gargron I am really happy that they are so forthcoming about the economic reality of running something like Signal.
However I wish they would be even more open about it, say by adding an optional yearly $10 subscription in the app, which does nothing functionally, aside perhaps adding a little star to your profile or something. I would happily help pay the bills, given the privacy promises they have a history of showing.
@DavidNielsen They have that already, at least in the iOS app. Interestingly it works exactly as you’ve proposed…
@moehrenfeld I haven’t used it in a while, but nice to know
@DavidNielsen So you would happily help to pay the bills even though you don’t use it? That’s awfully nice of you!