tbh they're right: random boycotts don't generally work. Most of my friends and family are similarly looking for wwhat they can to do help but don't have the time or energy (let alone money) for *everything* or even most things. Displacing sales from Friday to Thursday or Saturday doesn't actually impact anybody even if it's successful; and most people are only willing to invest a finite amount of inconvenience to various boycotts, so it's not necessarily a great use of that energy. Of course tactics like Economic Blackout can potentially be useful even if they don't have immediate direct impact, but at least so far with this particular project it's not clear to me they're doing the right things for long-term impact (as opposed to short-term merch sales).
By contrast Nina Turner and the faith leaders behind #TargetFast are,treating a boycott as just one prong in an overall organizing strategy -- plus they're and are doing things to maximize the chance of effectiveness. Tor example Target Fast is pairing it with a "buycott" to direct money to Black-owned businessess. Nina was
on the latest Under the Blacklight ... and they also had people like Damon Hewitt of Lawyers Committee on Civil RIghts and David J Johns of National Black Justice Coalition talking about some of the other organizing going on.
And Mariame Kaba has had some great perspectives on Bluesky as to why #TeslaTakedown is so effective -- as well as how to increase the effectiveness, for example by giving out leaflets with other actions people can take.
@seachanger